About Us Choose My Box Contact Gifts How it Works Our Products Recipes Suppliers
0 Off the Muck Market Logo
Refer a Friend
About Us Choose My Box Gifts How it Works Our Products Recipes Suppliers
Shopping for Wednesday, Oct 14 in 13020
Box & schedule chosen at signup
Shopping for Wednesday, Oct 14 in 13020 | Your Box: choose at signup | Your Schedule: choose at signup | Order minimum: $30 (your box counts toward it)
to shop home
Category
Deals & Savings

Add Ons and Extras
(3)
(4)
Dietary Lifestyle
(1)
(3)
(1)
(2)
(6)
Shop By Occasion
(52)
(1)
(23)
(17)
(2)
(1)
(4)
(7)
Values and Quality
(3)
(1)
(1)
(1)
(3)
Price






Top Brands
Product Tags
All-Natural Artisanal Authentic Bagel Baked Beverage Black Cherry Blueberry Breakfast Brooklyn Bucatini Cascatelli Charcuterie Cheddar Cheese Coal Oven Condiments Cream-On-Top Curated Curated Box Dairy Dairy Free Date Syrup Dinner Dry-Cured Farm Fresh Fermented Flavored Flavorful French French Toast Fresh Garlic Gluten Free Gourmet Hand-crafted Handcrafted Hosting Italian Jalapeño Limeade Local Margherita Meal Kit Meal Planning Meat Alternatives Medium Mixed Selection Multigrain Natural No Sugar Added Non-GMO Organic Pantry Parmesan Pasta Peach Pepperoni Pickles Plant-Based Pork Probiotic Produce Protein Quick Meals Ready to Eat Restaurant Style Rigatoni Rosemary Sausage Savory Seasonal Seasoning Sesame Small Batch Snack Snacks Soda Sourdough Sweet Sweet Treats Tender Tomato Variety Box Vegan Verde Versatile Whole Foods Whole Wheat Yogurt


Still looking for... something?
Describe what you want

Dairy & Eggs

Milk & Cream
Milk & Cream
Eggs
Eggs
Cheese
Cheese
Butter & Margarine
Butter & Margarine
Yogurt
Yogurt
Dairy Alternatives
Dairy Alternatives
1 - 40 of 89 Results
Sort by
14 Month Gruyere 14 Month Gruyere 8 oz
East Hill Creamery
14 Month Gruyere, 8 oz
$11.39

3 Year Aged Cheddar 3 Year Aged Cheddar ~8-10 oz.
Jake's Cheese
3 Year Aged Cheddar, ~8-10 oz.
$6.89

3 Year Old Cheddar 3 Year Old Cheddar 10 oz.
Adirondack Cheese
3 Year Old Cheddar, 10 oz.
$6.89

Aged Gouda Aged Gouda 8 oz.
Jake's Cheese
Aged Gouda, 8 oz.
$7.39

Blue Cheese Spread Blue Cheese Spread 8 oz.
only 4 left!
Adirondack Cheese
Blue Cheese Spread, 8 oz.
$4.09

Buffalo Wing Spread Buffalo Wing Spread 8 oz.
Adirondack Cheese
Buffalo Wing Spread, 8 oz.
$4.09

Cabot Cream Cheese Cabot Cream Cheese 8 oz.
Cabot Creamery
Cabot Cream Cheese, 8 oz.
$2.69

Camembert Cheese Camembert Cheese 5.5 oz.
Chaseholm Farms
Camembert Cheese, 5.5 oz.
$8.99

Cheddar and Pepperoni Cheese Cheddar and Pepperoni Cheese 10 oz.
Adirondack Cheese
Cheddar and Pepperoni Cheese, 10 oz.
$8.69
Sold Out!
Cheddar Cheese Spread Cheddar Cheese Spread 8 oz.
Adirondack Cheese
Cheddar Cheese Spread, 8 oz.
$4.09

Cheddar Lake Effect Cheddar Lake Effect 8 oz
Lively Run Dairy
Cheddar Lake Effect, 8 oz
$10.49

Chevre Mixed Herbs Chevre Mixed Herbs 5 oz.
Nettle Meadow Farm
Chevre Mixed Herbs, 5 oz.
$6.49
Sold Out!
Dill Cheddar Cheese Dill Cheddar Cheese 10 oz.
Adirondack Cheese
Dill Cheddar Cheese, 10 oz.
$7.09

Dill Spread Dill Spread 8 oz.
Adirondack Cheese
Dill Spread, 8 oz.
$4.09

Fromage Frais Maple Fromage Frais Maple 5 oz.
Nettle Meadow Farm
Fromage Frais Maple, 5 oz.
$5.59

Fromage Frais Mixed Milk Fig & Honey Fromage Frais Mixed Milk Fig & Honey 5 oz.
Nettle Meadow Farm
Fromage Frais Mixed Milk Fig & Honey, 5 oz.
$5.99

Garlic And Herb Spread Garlic And Herb Spread 8 oz.
Adirondack Cheese
Garlic And Herb Spread, 8 oz.
$4.09

Havarti Cheese Havarti Cheese 6 oz.
only 1 left!
North Country Creamery
Havarti Cheese, 6 oz.
$8.49

Havarti Cheese Havarti Cheese 8 oz
Argyle Cheese Farmer
Havarti Cheese, 8 oz
$7.69

Hickory Smoked Cheddar Hickory Smoked Cheddar 10 oz.
Adirondack Cheese
Hickory Smoked Cheddar, 10 oz.
$7.09

Hot Pepper Cheese Spread Hot Pepper Cheese Spread 8 oz
only 2 left!
Adirondack Cheese
Hot Pepper Cheese Spread, 8 oz
$4.09

Hungarian Wax Pepper Creme Cheese Hungarian Wax Pepper Creme Cheese 8 oz.
only 4 left!
Jones Family Farm
Hungarian Wax Pepper Creme Cheese, 8 oz.
$4.49

Jalapeno Horseradish Spread Jalapeno Horseradish Spread 8 oz
Adirondack Cheese
Jalapeno Horseradish Spread, 8 oz
$4.09

Maple Bacon Cheddar Spread Maple Bacon Cheddar Spread 8 oz.
only 3 left!
Adirondack Cheese
Maple Bacon Cheddar Spread, 8 oz.
$4.09

Peppercorn And Chive Spread Peppercorn And Chive Spread 8 oz.
only 3 left!
Adirondack Cheese
Peppercorn And Chive Spread, 8 oz.
$4.09

Smokehouse Bacon Cheddar Spread Smokehouse Bacon Cheddar Spread 8 oz
Adirondack Cheese
Smokehouse Bacon Cheddar Spread, 8 oz
$4.09

Sundried Tomato and Basil Spread Sundried Tomato and Basil Spread 8 oz.
Adirondack Cheese
Sundried Tomato and Basil Spread, 8 oz.
$4.09

Triple Cream Cheese Adiron-Jack Triple Cream Cheese Adiron-Jack 8 oz.
Nettle Meadow Farm
Triple Cream Cheese Adiron-Jack, 8 oz.
$13.19

Triple Cream Nimbus Cheese Triple Cream Nimbus Cheese 8 oz.
Chaseholm Farms
Triple Cream Nimbus Cheese, 8 oz.
$12.49

White American Cheese Slices - 12 oz. White American Cheese Slices - 12 oz. package
Cabot Creamery
White American Cheese Slices - 12 oz., package
$3.99

White Gold Cheddar White Gold Cheddar 10 oz.
Adirondack Cheese
White Gold Cheddar, 10 oz.
$9.69

Cream on Top Chocolate Milk Pint Cream on Top Chocolate Milk Pint each
Upper Grove Farmstead
Cream on Top Chocolate Milk Pint, each
$2.29

Cultured Buttermilk Cultured Buttermilk quart
Pittsford Dairy
Cultured Buttermilk, quart
$4.39

Heavy Cream Heavy Cream pint
Pittsford Dairy
Heavy Cream, pint
$5.19

Black Cherry Yogurt 32oz Black Cherry Yogurt 32oz 32 oz
Ithaca Milk
Black Cherry Yogurt 32oz, 32 oz
$4.89

Blueberry Yogurt 32oz Blueberry Yogurt 32oz 32 oz.
only 2 left!
Stoltzfus Family Dairy
Blueberry Yogurt 32oz, 32 oz.
$5.29

Blueberry Yogurt 32oz* Blueberry Yogurt 32oz* 32 oz
Ithaca Milk
Blueberry Yogurt 32oz*, 32 oz
$4.89

Blueberry Yogurt 6oz Blueberry Yogurt 6oz 6 oz.
Stoltzfus Family Dairy
Blueberry Yogurt 6oz, 6 oz.
$1.39

Cream on Top Black Cherry Yogurt Cream on Top Black Cherry Yogurt 6 oz. cup
Ithaca Milk
Cream on Top Black Cherry Yogurt, 6 oz. cup
$1.49

Cream On Top Blueberry Yogurt Cream On Top Blueberry Yogurt 6 oz. cup
Ithaca Milk
Cream On Top Blueberry Yogurt, 6 oz. cup
$1.49





Home

Shop

Past Orders

Cart

Account