About Us Choose My Box Contact Gifts How it Works Our Products Recipes Suppliers
0 Off the Muck Market Logo
Refer a Friend
About Us Choose My Box Gifts How it Works Our Products Recipes Suppliers
Shopping for Wednesday, Oct 14 in 13020
Box & schedule chosen at signup
Shopping for Wednesday, Oct 14 in 13020 | Your Box: choose at signup | Your Schedule: choose at signup | Order minimum: $30 (your box counts toward it)
to shop home
Category
Deals & Savings

Add Ons and Extras
(3)
(4)
Dietary Lifestyle
(1)
(3)
(1)
(2)
(6)
Shop By Occasion
(52)
(1)
(23)
(17)
(2)
(1)
(4)
(7)
Values and Quality
(3)
(1)
(1)
(1)
(3)
Price






Top Brands
Product Tags
All-Natural Artisanal Authentic Bagel Baked Beverage Black Cherry Blueberry Breakfast Brooklyn Bucatini Cascatelli Charcuterie Cheddar Cheese Coal Oven Condiments Cream-On-Top Curated Curated Box Dairy Dairy Free Date Syrup Dinner Dry-Cured Farm Fresh Fermented Flavored Flavorful French French Toast Fresh Garlic Gluten Free Gourmet Hand-crafted Handcrafted Hosting Italian Jalapeño Limeade Local Margherita Meal Kit Meal Planning Meat Alternatives Medium Mixed Selection Multigrain Natural No Sugar Added Non-GMO Organic Pantry Parmesan Pasta Peach Pepperoni Pickles Plant-Based Pork Probiotic Produce Protein Quick Meals Ready to Eat Restaurant Style Rigatoni Rosemary Sausage Savory Seasonal Seasoning Sesame Small Batch Snack Snacks Soda Sourdough Sweet Sweet Treats Tender Tomato Variety Box Vegan Verde Versatile Whole Foods Whole Wheat Yogurt


Still looking for... something?
Describe what you want

Dairy & Eggs

Milk & Cream
Milk & Cream
Eggs
Eggs
Cheese
Cheese
Butter & Margarine
Butter & Margarine
Yogurt
Yogurt
Dairy Alternatives
Dairy Alternatives
41 - 80 of 89 Results
Sort by
Cream On Top Maple Yogurt Cream On Top Maple Yogurt 6 oz. cup
Ithaca Milk
Cream On Top Maple Yogurt, 6 oz. cup
$1.49
Sold Out!
Cream On Top Peach Yogurt Cream On Top Peach Yogurt 6 oz. cup
only 4 left!
Ithaca Milk
Cream On Top Peach Yogurt, 6 oz. cup
$1.49

Cream on Top Plain Yogurt Cream on Top Plain Yogurt 6 oz. cup
Ithaca Milk
Cream on Top Plain Yogurt, 6 oz. cup
$1.49

Cream On Top Strawberry Yogurt Cream On Top Strawberry Yogurt 6 oz. cup
only 4 left!
Ithaca Milk
Cream On Top Strawberry Yogurt, 6 oz. cup
$1.49

Cream On Top Vanilla Yogurt Cream On Top Vanilla Yogurt 6 oz. cup
Ithaca Milk
Cream On Top Vanilla Yogurt, 6 oz. cup
$1.49

Maple Yogurt 32oz* Maple Yogurt 32oz* 32 oz
Ithaca Milk
Maple Yogurt 32oz*, 32 oz
$5.19

Peach Yogurt 32oz Peach Yogurt 32oz 32 oz
Ithaca Milk
Peach Yogurt 32oz, 32 oz
$4.89

Plain Yogurt 32oz Plain Yogurt 32oz 32 oz
Ithaca Milk
Plain Yogurt 32oz, 32 oz
$4.89

Raspberry Yogurt 32oz Raspberry Yogurt 32oz 32 oz.
only 4 left!
Stoltzfus Family Dairy
Raspberry Yogurt 32oz, 32 oz.
$5.29

Raspberry Yogurt 6oz Raspberry Yogurt 6oz 6 oz.
only 4 left!
Stoltzfus Family Dairy
Raspberry Yogurt 6oz, 6 oz.
$1.39

Strawberry Yogurt 32oz Strawberry Yogurt 32oz 32 oz.
only 4 left!
Stoltzfus Family Dairy
Strawberry Yogurt 32oz, 32 oz.
$5.29

Strawberry Yogurt 32oz* Strawberry Yogurt 32oz* 32 oz
Ithaca Milk
Strawberry Yogurt 32oz*, 32 oz
$4.89

Strawberry Yogurt 6oz Strawberry Yogurt 6oz 6 oz.
Stoltzfus Family Dairy
Strawberry Yogurt 6oz, 6 oz.
$1.39

Vanilla Yogurt 32oz Vanilla Yogurt 32oz 32 oz
Ithaca Milk
Vanilla Yogurt 32oz, 32 oz
$4.89

Salted Rolled Butter Salted Rolled Butter 1 lb.
Kriemhild Dairy Farms
Salted Rolled Butter, 1 lb.
$15.69

Coconut Milk Chaokoh Coconut Milk Chaokoh 13.5 oz.
Coconut Milk , 13.5 oz.
$2.59

Eggs Large Non-GMO Pasture Raised Eggs Large Non-GMO Pasture Raised dozen
Early Bird Farmers Cooperative
Eggs Large Non-GMO Pasture Raised, dozen
$2.89

Eggs Large ORGANIC Non-GMO Pasture Raised Eggs Large ORGANIC Non-GMO Pasture Raised dozen
Early Bird Farmers Cooperative
Eggs Large ORGANIC Non-GMO Pasture Raised, dozen
$3.79

Plain Grass Fed Yogurt Plain Grass Fed Yogurt 32 oz.
North Country Creamery
Plain Grass Fed Yogurt, 32 oz.
$7.59

1/2 Gallon - Whole Milk 1/2 Gallon - Whole Milk each
Upper Grove Farmstead
1/2 Gallon - Whole Milk, each
$3.99

Gallon - Whole Milk Gallon - Whole Milk each
Upper Grove Farmstead
Gallon - Whole Milk, each
$6.59

Blueberry Cardamom Lassi Blueberry Cardamom Lassi 8 oz.
only 1 left!
Indian Milk and Honey
Blueberry Cardamom Lassi, 8 oz.
$1.39

Whole Milk - Gallon Whole Milk - Gallon gallon
Dygert Farms Creamery
Whole Milk - Gallon
$4.09

Sour Cream Sour Cream 8 oz
only 3 left!
Cabot Creamery
Sour Cream, 8 oz
$1.39

Salted Sweet Cream Butter Salted Sweet Cream Butter 1 lb.
Cabot Creamery
Salted Sweet Cream Butter, 1 lb.
$5.19

Chocolate 1/2 Gallon Milk Chocolate 1/2 Gallon Milk 64 oz
Dygert Farms Creamery
Chocolate 1/2 Gallon Milk, 64 oz
$3.39

Half and Half - 1/2 Gallon Half and Half - 1/2 Gallon Half Gallon
Dygert Farms Creamery
Half and Half - 1/2 Gallon, Half Gallon
$4.59

Chocolate Milk - Single Serve Chocolate Milk - Single Serve pint
Dygert Farms Creamery
Chocolate Milk - Single Serve, pint
$1.59

Half and Half - Pint Half and Half - Pint pint
Dygert Farms Creamery
Half and Half - Pint
$1.79

Lemon Creamline Yogurt Lemon Creamline Yogurt 32 oz.
only 2 left!
North Country Creamery
Lemon Creamline Yogurt, 32 oz.
$8.69

Half and Half - Quart Half and Half - Quart 1 quart
Dygert Farms Creamery
Half and Half - Quart, 1 quart
$2.89

Maple Grass Fed Creamline Yogurt Maple Grass Fed Creamline Yogurt 32 oz.
only 4 left!
North Country Creamery
Maple Grass Fed Creamline Yogurt, 32 oz.
$8.69

Whole Milk - 1/2 Gallon Whole Milk - 1/2 Gallon Half Gallon
Dygert Farms Creamery
Whole Milk - 1/2 Gallon, Half Gallon
$2.59

Chocolate 1/2 Gallon Milk Chocolate 1/2 Gallon Milk each
Upper Grove Farmstead
Chocolate 1/2 Gallon Milk, each
$4.59

Reduced Fat Milk- 1/2 Gal Reduced Fat Milk- 1/2 Gal Half Gallon
Dygert Farms Creamery
Reduced Fat Milk- 1/2 Gal, Half Gallon
$2.59

Chocolate Milk - Quart Chocolate Milk - Quart 1 quart
Dygert Farms Creamery
Chocolate Milk - Quart, 1 quart
$2.49

Mango and Rosewater Lassi Mango and Rosewater Lassi 8 oz.
Indian Milk and Honey
Mango and Rosewater Lassi, 8 oz.
$1.39

Sour Cream Sour Cream 16 oz
Cabot Creamery
Sour Cream, 16 oz
$3.09

Unsalted Sweet Cream Butter Unsalted Sweet Cream Butter lb
Cabot Creamery
Unsalted Sweet Cream Butter, lb
$5.19

New York Creme Cheese New York Creme Cheese 8 oz.
Jones Family Farm
New York Creme Cheese, 8 oz.
$3.69





Home

Shop

Past Orders

Cart

Account