Skip to content Accessibility Notice Statement
Loading...
loading gif
Hello, Guest
  • Trending
  • Bestsellers
  • New Releases
  • Movers & Shakers
  • Shop
  • Dairy & Eggs
    • Dairy & Eggs
    • All Products
    • Milk & Cream
    • Eggs
    • Cheese
    • Butter & Margarine
    • See More
    • Yogurt
    • Dairy Alternatives
    • See Less
  • Proteins
    • Proteins
    • All Products
    • Beef
    • Chicken
    • Hotdogs & Sausage
    • Pork
    • See More
    • Bacon
    • Turkey
    • Meat Alternatives
    • See Less
  • Breads, Rolls & Bakery
    • Breads, Rolls & Bakery
    • All Products
    • Breads
    • Rolls & Buns
    • Breakfast Bakery
    • See Less
  • Fresh Vegetables
  • See More
  • Fresh Fruit
  • Greens
  • Fresh Herbs
  • Pantry Essentials
    • Pantry Essentials
    • All Products
    • Baking
    • Jam, Jellies & Nut Butters
    • Sauces
    • Soups & Broths
    • See More
    • Canned Goods
    • Condiments & Dressings
    • Pasta & Noodles
    • Cereal
    • Spices & Seasonings
    • See Less
  • Frozen Foods
    • Frozen Foods
    • All Products
    • Frozen Fruits & Vegetables
    • Frozen Entrees & Appetizers
    • See Less
  • Beverages
    • Beverages
    • All Products
    • Juice
    • Coffee
    • Kombucha & Tea
    • See More
    • Tea
    • Water, Seltzer & Sparkling Water
    • Soft Drinks
    • See Less
  • Snacks, Chips, Salsas & Dips
    • Snacks, Chips, Salsas & Dips
    • All Products
    • Chips
    • Candy & Chocolate
    • Salsas, Dips & Spreads
    • Jerky
    • Crackers
    • Popcorn, Puffs & Rice Cakes
    • Nuts, Seeds & Dried Fruit
    • See Less
  • Seafood
    • Seafood
    • All Products
    • Fish
    • See Less
  • Supplements
    • Supplements
    • All Products
    • Wellness & Seasonal
    • See Less
  • Lifestyle
    • Lifestyle
    • All Products
    • Home & Kitchen
    • See Less
  • Desserts
    • Desserts
    • All Products
    • Cookies
    • See Less
  • Gift Cards
  • Pet
    • Pet
    • All Products
    • Dog
    • Cat
    • See Less
  • Body Care
    • Body Care
    • All Products
    • Baby & Child
    • Personal Care
    • See Less
  • Bundle
  • Bulk Items
  • See Less
  • Learn More
  • Our Products
  • How it Works
  • About Us
  • Suppliers
  • See More
  • Recipes
  • Choose My Box
  • Our Vendors
  • Testimonials
  • See Less
  • Help & Settings
  • Sign Up Today!
  • Get Help
  • Login







Our Products How it Works About Us Suppliers Recipes Choose My Box Contact
Off The Muck Market Logo
log in to your account
| sign up
Off The Muck Market Logo
Log In | Sign Up
Our Products How it Works About Us Suppliers Recipes Choose My Box

Hi there! Please log in or sign up to shop.

SIGN UP TODAY!


  • Shop Home /
  • Dairy & Eggs /
  • Cheese

Super XXX Sharp Cheddar - Local

Buttercup Cheese
Super XXX Sharp Cheddar - Local Main Image
Super XXX Sharp Cheddar - Local Image 0
Super XXX Sharp Cheddar - Local Image 1
Super XXX Sharp Cheddar - Local Image 2
Super XXX Sharp Cheddar - Local Image 3
Super XXX Sharp Cheddar - Local Thumbnail Image 0
Super XXX Sharp Cheddar - Local Thumbnail Image 1
Super XXX Sharp Cheddar - Local Thumbnail Image 2
Super XXX Sharp Cheddar - Local Thumbnail Image 3
Super XXX Sharp Cheddar - Local Thumbnail Image 4

Super XXX Sharp Cheddar - Local

Buttercup Cheese
$10.99
Unit: lb.
Sold Out!
Pride of NY- Used on NY products.

  • Description

Description

This one has a bite! Aged to perfection, this Super XXX Sharp Cheddar is sure to satisfy any cheese lover that appreciates cheddar's distinct flavor. We recommend enjoying it on crackers or adding it as a side to some sweet fruit! Add it as an ingredient to your favorite recipes at your own risk — it has a tendency of stealing the show with its deliciousness!

Recipes:

Cheddar Apple Butternut Soup

Creamy Kombucha Cheddar Cheese Soup

Savory Spinach & Broccoli Quiche

Vegetable Chowder


Share with friends!

More Best Sellers from Cheese
3 Year Aged Cheddar - Local 3 Year Aged Cheddar - Local 8 oz.
Jake's Gouda
3 Year Aged Cheddar - Local, 8 oz.
Pride of NY- Used on NY products.
$7.49
3 Year Old Cheddar - Local 3 Year Old Cheddar - Local 10 oz.
Adirondack Cheese
3 Year Old Cheddar - Local, 10 oz.
Pride of NY- Used on NY products.
$9.49
Aged Gouda - Local Aged Gouda - Local 8 oz.
only 1 left!
Jake's Gouda
Aged Gouda - Local, 8 oz.
Pride of NY- Used on NY products.
$8.99
Buffalo Wing Spread - local Buffalo Wing Spread - local 8 oz.
Adirondack Cheese
Buffalo Wing Spread - local, 8 oz.
Pride of NY- Used on NY products.
$6.99
Burrata Cream Filled Mozzarella - Local Burrata Cream Filled Mozzarella - Local 4 oz.
Maplebrook Farm
Burrata Cream Filled Mozzarella - Local, 4 oz.
Pride of NY- Used on NY products.
$5.99
Cabot Cream Cheese Cabot Cream Cheese 8 oz.
Cabot Creamery
Cabot Cream Cheese, 8 oz.
$3.49
Camembert Cheese - Local Camembert Cheese - Local 5.5 oz.
only 4 left!
Chaseholm Farms
Camembert Cheese - Local, 5.5 oz.
Pride of NY- Used on NY products.
$8.99
Cheddar Cheese Spread - Local Cheddar Cheese Spread - Local 8 oz.
Adirondack Cheese
Cheddar Cheese Spread - Local, 8 oz.
Pride of NY- Used on NY products.
$6.99
Cheddar, Lake Effect - Local Cheddar, Lake Effect - Local 8 oz
Lively Run Dairy
Cheddar, Lake Effect - Local, 8 oz
Pride of NY- Used on NY products.
$12.99
Chevre, Maple - Local Chevre, Maple - Local 8 oz.
only 4 left!
Nettle Meadow
Chevre, Maple - Local, 8 oz.
Pride of NY- Used on NY products.
$4.99
Chevre, Meyer Lemon & Cardamom - Local Chevre, Meyer Lemon & Cardamom - Local 5 oz.
only 4 left!
Nettle Meadow
Chevre, Meyer Lemon & Cardamom - Local, 5 oz.
Pride of NY- Used on NY products.
$4.99
Chevre, Mixed Herbs - Local Chevre, Mixed Herbs - Local 5 oz.
only 3 left!
Nettle Meadow
Chevre, Mixed Herbs - Local, 5 oz.
Pride of NY- Used on NY products.
$4.99
Ewe's Blue Cheese - Local Ewe's Blue Cheese - Local 6 oz
only 4 left!
Ewe's Blue Cheese
Ewe's Blue Cheese - Local, 6 oz
Pride of NY- Used on NY products.
$11.49
Fresh Ciliegine Mozzarella - Local Fresh Ciliegine Mozzarella - Local 8 oz.
only 2 left!
Maplebrook Farm
Fresh Ciliegine Mozzarella - Local, 8 oz.
Pride of NY- Used on NY products.
$5.29
Fresh Ricotta - Local Fresh Ricotta - Local 16 oz.
only 3 left!
Maplebrook Farm
Fresh Ricotta - Local, 16 oz.
Pride of NY- Used on NY products.
$5.99
Fromage Frais, Mixed Milk, Fig & Honey - Local Fromage Frais, Mixed Milk, Fig & Honey - Local 5 oz.
only 2 left!
Nettle Meadow
Fromage Frais, Mixed Milk, Fig & Honey - Local, 5 oz.
Pride of NY- Used on NY products.
$6.59
View More

Shop

Shop Past Orders

Home

My Order

Account
Quick Links
About Us
Choose My Box
How it Works
Login
Our Products
Recipes
Shop
Sign Up
Suppliers
Accessibility Notice Statement
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Follow us


Gifts
Gift Certificates
Send a Gift Box



We Love Local
Are you a local artisan or farmer? Get in Touch!

Off The Muck Market
Office Hours:

Mon-Thurs 9-5
Fri 9-4

[email protected]
 www.offthemuck.com/


Powered by Stripe Payments
© Copyright 2024 Off The Muck Market. All Rights Reserved. 30 Madison Blvd, Canastota, NY 13032 Privacy Policy & Terms of Service
Terms of Service


Loading

------------------------------------------------- -------------------------------------------------